Healthcare Apartheid: How Legal and Infrastructure Inequality Betrays Rural Lives

SURABAYA – Bring geography into the picture and the universal guarantee of healthcare comes crashing down. Depending on where you live (e determines if you are treated or abandoned and allowed to die slowly from treatable ailments. It's not a tragic mismatch. It is separate but unequal justice for health rights.

Just call it healthcare apartheid. Large cities have state of the art hospitals, specialist doctors and complex legal protections for patients and providers. Simultaneously, in rural and remote areas clinics are bare-bones, medical staffing has always been problematic shrivelling staff pools to virtually nothing and lack of laws renders a de facto invisibility. This gap is thus not merely logistical, but a juridical one.

Urban patients exist in systems with defined standards of care, aspirationally more transparent liability regimes with access to justice. In contrast, rural populations are often forced to survive in areas with a chasm of legal ambiguity where malpractice is more difficult to prove, systems of national accountability exist only on paper and enforcement happens at best infrequently. Rights that exist on paper evaporate in practice.

This difference lays bare a much deeper truth: the right to health is being rationed by geography. This imbalance is often justified by reference to resource constraints or sequencing of development on the part of governments.

But these arguments hide an even less comfortable truth: policy options will always favor urban constituencies and most public policy decisions will institutionalize rural neglect. Infrastructure does not follow human need, it follows political power.

The consequences are devastating. Rural health care continues to be defined by delayed diagnoses, preventable deaths, untreated chronic illness and maternal morbidity and dare I say mortality that would be anathema in any urban centre. Still, these results seldom create a sense of legal urgency. They get fed instead into a silent story of inevitability.

This latter normalization is a structural violence in itself. As concerning is how legal systems have yet to catch up. Many health law frameworks assume the presence of adequate, professional capacity and infrastructure, conditions that simply do not exist in most remote settings.

Consequently, such legal standards are uninformed and too remote from lived realities thus making any outcome to be both impractical and unjust when it comes to effective accountability. For doctors working in under-resourced settings, these risks are grossly unequal and patients continue to be systematically unprotected.

In this context, law is not a remedy for inequality. Closing this gap needs more than half measure change. It requires a deep reimagination of health rights and their actualisation through different geographies. It requires reallocation of investments, readjustment of legal frameworks and the extension of transparency and accountability mechanisms to areas beyond urban islands.

Anything else sustains a two-tier system in which survival itself is something conditional, a function of where you stand.

Until states oust this inequity with structural seriousness, the claim to universal health care will just stay right that a claim. For millions who live outside the protective shadow of urban privilege, the right to health will remain an unkept pledge.

***

*) By: Fransiscus Nanga Roka, Faculty of Law University 17 August 1945 Surabaya, Managing Partner of Law Firm Victorious Indonesia and Member of Indonesian Medical Association.

*) This opinion piece is entirely the responsibility of the author and is not the responsibility of the timesindonesia.co.id editorial team.

*) Kopi TIMES or the opinion section in TIMES Indonesia is for the general public. The maximum length of the article is 4,000 characters or approximately 600 words.

*) Include the author's name, profession, photo, and contact number.

*) Manuscripts should be sent to https://kopi.times.co.id/

*) The editorial team reserves the right not to publish submitted opinions.

Simak breaking news dan berita pilihan TIMES Indonesia langsung dari WhatsApp-mu!
Klik 👉 Channel TIMES Indonesia
Pastikan WhatsApp kamu sudah terpasang.